Come visit us in the Fall. Many markets are scheduled.

TheIslandCookieJar
Home
Owners
Christmas Baked Goods
Baked Goods
Contact Us
Gallery
Future Events
Tips
Cookies
Loaves & Breads
Sugar Cookies
Tea Biscuits
Biscotti
Cakes and Custom Cakes
TheIslandCookieJar
Home
Owners
Christmas Baked Goods
Baked Goods
Contact Us
Gallery
Future Events
Tips
Cookies
Loaves & Breads
Sugar Cookies
Tea Biscuits
Biscotti
Cakes and Custom Cakes
More
  • Home
  • Owners
  • Christmas Baked Goods
  • Baked Goods
  • Contact Us
  • Gallery
  • Future Events
  • Tips
  • Cookies
  • Loaves & Breads
  • Sugar Cookies
  • Tea Biscuits
  • Biscotti
  • Cakes and Custom Cakes
  • Home
  • Owners
  • Christmas Baked Goods
  • Baked Goods
  • Contact Us
  • Gallery
  • Future Events
  • Tips
  • Cookies
  • Loaves & Breads
  • Sugar Cookies
  • Tea Biscuits
  • Biscotti
  • Cakes and Custom Cakes

Sugar Cookie Styles

Sugar Cookies

Heart-shaped cookies decorated with pink, white, and red icing.

Hearts

Two yellow chick-shaped cookies wrapped in clear plastic.

Chicks

A decorated Santa Claus cookie with white beard and red hat.

Santa Face

A penguin-shaped Christmas cookie with a Santa hat and decorated with icing and sprinkles.

Penguins

Smiling snowman cookie with a red hat decorated with holly.

Snowman Face

Swirling Hearts

Third Item

Santa Belly

Onesie

Baby Outfit

Igloo

Bunny

Green Monster

Friends

Snowflake

Minion

Purple Monster

Lobster

Crab

Anchor

Newfoundland

Puffin

Whale

Boat

Black Bear

Eye

Hot Dog

Beer Stein

Coffee Cup

Batman

Spiderman

Graduation

Note: Any character or style is available. Let us know what you are looking for and the occasion.

Price List

Sugar Cookies $6.00 each

All cookies are available in different flavours. No minimum on plain vanilla.  Minimum  6 each for other flavours.

                               Flavours available are:  

Plain

Orange

Lemon

Almond

Mexican Hot Chocolate

Chocolate


Note: All cookies are 5". Flavours available are almond, orange, lemon, plain, chocolate. Minimum order of 6 for each flavour except for plain. No minimum for plain.

Copyright © 2026 TheIslandCookieJar - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

  • Privacy Policy
  • Tips

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept